I have an older Felicity with the bright red hair and the newer Mattel with albrun hair. The faces look totally different. In my album the first photo of the pilgrim outfits are worn my an older Felicity and Samantha. Both of these dolls came from the flee market. There hair was very frizzy. Thanks to your info on the downy dunk and Cherry's tips on curling, they now have pretty hair. I like the older Felicity best. If I could bear to part with a doll I would sell the newer one. So far I haven't been able to sell any of my dolls. I've become an AG addict. (LOL) I blame my addiction on Cherry and her photos.